The principle of gillick competence was stated in the english house of lords in gillick v west norfolk aha1986 ac 112. The first appellant, west norfolk and wisbech area health authority, was not represented when the appeal reached this house, but in the court of appeal it was represented by the same counsel as the dhss. Under uk law a child moves into official adulthood at the point of their eighteenth birthday children act 1989 s105. Report of the committee of inquiry into human fertilisation and. Stephen gilmore, jonathan herring, rebecca probert. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha united kingdom house of lords 17 oct, 1985 17 oct, 1985. However, the judge consent disclosure of risk 51 note always ask the patient if he has understood the information that. In gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area authority. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha 1985 ukhl 7. Parker ljs judgment was the most substantial of the three delivered.
Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 19845 gillick competence any child who is under the age of 16 can consent, if he or she reaches a sufficient understanding and intelligence to be capable of making up his own mind on the matter requiring decision. The child must be capable of making a reasonable assessment of the advantages and disadvantages of the treatment proposed, so the consent, if given, can be properly and fairly described as true consent. This is essentially a child under the age of 16 who has been deemed to understand all aspects of the advice given to them by their doctor relating to their medical heath, treatment and procedures. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha kings student law. The scope and potential reform of the defence of necessity. Grin the scope and potential reform of the defence of. She is, to use the language of woolf j as he then was in gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1984 qb 581 at p 596, capable of making a reasonable assessment of the advantages and disadvantages of what is proposed.
The ruling in this case provides that the childs voice is listened to in court when they reach a sufficient understanding to be capable of making up their own mind. T 2010, essential law for counsellors and psychotherapists, legal resources for counsellors and. Special considerations in physiology and trial design. The family planning association has welcomed the judgement. Victoria gillick mrs gillick, against the order of woolf j 1984 1 all er 365, 1984. Capacity of children to make legal decisions the childs wishes and decisions in the family courts. The case of gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha7 was a giant leap in childrens. House of lords in gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 19845. The courts have so far declined invitations to define rigidly gillick competence and the individual doctor is free to make a decision, consulting peers if this may be helpful, as to whether that child is gillick competent. Landmark cases in family law landmark cases stephen. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority and.
Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1984 5 ministry of ethics. For an excellent commentary on gillick s case, see p. In analysing the reasons that australian medical orthodoxy holds to its present view, recourse is often made to english cases pre gillick. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha and another 1985 3 wlr 830 24, 25, 42, 99, 100. Not merely rights for children but childrens rights. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority and department of health and social security 1986. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1984 5 gillick competence any child who is under the age of 16 can consent, if he or she reaches a sufficient understanding and intelligence to be capable of making up his own mind on the matter requiring decision. It is important to treat each case or situation on an individual basis. In this important house of lords case, it was held that a minors capacity to make decisions was dependent on his or her individual maturity. This third book in the authoritative bacp legal resources for counsellors and psychotherapists series provides a userfriendly guide to the law for all those. He edited archbishop peter a comensolis book, in gods image.
This study of the implications of gillick competence argues it is an unnecessary burden with an unethical foundation. A minor is, according to this principle, capable of giving informed consent when he or she achieves a sufficient understanding or intelligence to enable him or her to understand fully what is proposed. I ii 1 i i iif i the house of lords and the preceding decisions in gillick v west norfolk and wispech area health authority 1986 ac 112 r, hl. The department of health and social security the dhss appealed with leave of the court of appeal against the decision of that court eveleigh, fox and parker ljj 1985 1 all er 533, 1985 2 wlr 4 on 20 december 1984 allowing an appeal by the respondent, victoria gillick mrs gillick, against the order of woolf j 1984 1 all er 365, 1984 qb 581 hearing the crown office list on 26 july 1983. Landmark cases in family law by stephen gilmore, 9781849461016, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. She sought a declaration that it would be unlawful for a doctor to prescribe contraceptives to girls under 16 without the knowledge or consent of the parent. Under uk law a child moves into official adulthood at the point of. The abolition of the marital rape exemption jonathan herring. As frankie is there to sell a service, this is a legitimate purpose and on the facts there has been no revocation of the licence plenty v dillon 1991 171 clr 635 as the gate was not locked.
The case involved a declaration from mrs gillick, based on a. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1986 ac 112 consent capacity of minors competence to consent to medical. Woolf j refused to grant the declarations sought by mrs gillick and dismissed the action see 1984 1 all er 365, 1984 qb 581. The book gives communication with relatives as an exception to. Throughout this book it has been emphasised that a rightsbased approach to social work practice with children is both a legal and professional requirement. The standard is based on the 1985 decision of the house of lords in gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority. Summary australian torts law lecture 2, exam notes. Such children are deemed to be capable of giving valid consent to advice or treatment without parental knowledge or agreement provided they have sufficient understanding to appreciate the nature, purpose, and. The means by which to assess legal capacity in children under the age of 16 years, established in the case gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1985 2 a11 er 402. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority. Read all of the posts by iwan dowie on iwan dowie law, ethics, politics and professional issues lse usw skip to content. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1986 1 ac 112 hl facts g, a mother of five girls, sought a declaration that guidance to doctors that they could in certain circumstances provide contraceptive treatment and advice to girls under 16 without their parents consent, was unlawful.
Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority and department of health and social security 1984 q. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority and department of health and social security 1986 ac 112 the gillick decision not just a highwater mark jane fortin 12. Capacity of children to make legal decisions gillick. Gillick competence is a term originating in england and is used in medical law to decide. Such children are deemed to be capable of giving valid consent to advice or treatment without parental knowledge or agreement provided they have sufficient. West norfolk and wisbech area health authority and another, all england law reports, 1984, pp. It was long thought that a child lacked legal capacity to give valid consent in law regarding decisions such as living arrangements, contracts, or consenting to medicalsurgicaldental procedures. In the case of gillick v west norfolk and wisbech health authority 1986 1 ac 112 lord scarman said, at 185e. The gillick competency and fraser guidelines help people who work with children to balance the need to listen to childrens wishes with the responsibility to keep them safe. Englands court of appeal, civil division, ruled that parents had the right to prevent a physician at the local health authority from prescribing contraceptives to girls under the age of 16 without parental consent.
Therapy with children is a vital resource for any practitioner navigating the legal minefield of working with children and young people. Similar provision is made in scotland by the age of legal capacity scotland act 1991. Children, gillick competency and consent for involvement in. The book gives communication with relatives as an exception to confidentiality between doctor and patient. She says she has received thousands of letters of support and has the backing of the national housewives association with its 25,000 members. It was explicitly endorsed by the other two lords justice, see gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1986 1 ac 112 ca and hl per fox lj at 146, eveleigh lj at 146. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them.
At my interview in january i had been asked whether the reform of child care law or the reform of the ground for divorce should be the priority. Rights and interests of children ministry of ethics. Children and consent to medical treatment can be particularly complex. The respondent, mrs gillick, maintains that he cannot. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority and another 1986 1 ac. Their lordships considered whether children under sixteen may be sufficiently mature to make medical decisions. Nov 27, 2017 stevenson 1932 ac 562 17 20 75 83 gaskin v united kingdom 1990 12 ehrr 36 20 gillick v. References 1 gillick v west norfolk and wisbech health.
The right of a child under 16 to consent to medical examination and treatment, including immunization was decided by the house of lords in gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha 1986 where a mother of girls under 16 objected to department of health advice that allowed doctors to give contraceptive advice and treatment to children without parental consent. The case of gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha itself and r on the application of axon v secretary of state for health. Until the decision of the house of lords in gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority20 the statement of the latey committee could be said to represent the predominant view in england. West norfolk and wisbech area health authority and anr. Landmark cases in family law 2011 is a book of chapters contributed by various authors, which outlines the key cases in english family law. Gillick competence any child who is under the age of 16 can consent, if he. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority and department of health and social security 1986 ac 112 the gillick decision. Timeline of young peoples rights in the united kingdom.
Nov 18, 2016 the 1985 house of lords case gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha,1 changed the traditional legal position which automatically treated parents as proxyconsent givers. References 1 gillick v west norfolk and wisbech health authority 1986 1 ac 112 from medicine 911 at eastern virginia medical school. Parental responsibility, young children and healthcare law this book provides a critical analysis of the law governing the provision of healthcare to young and dependent children, identifying an understanding of the child as vulnerable and in need of protection, including from his or her own parents. This book provides indepth studies of some of the leading family law cases which have shaped modern family law in england and wales.
Gillick competence is a term originating in england and is used in medical law to decide whether a child under 16 years of age is able to consent to his or her own medical treatment, without the need for parental permission or knowledge the standard is based on the 1985 decision of the house of lords in gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. Mrs gillick, a roman catholic, has been in a fouryear dispute over the issue with west norfolk and wisbech health authority. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha 1985 ukhl 7 united. The court of appeal was unanimous in rejecting mrs gillick s arguments. Upon report from the appellate committee to whom was referred the cause gillick against west norfolk and wisbech area health authority and the department of health and social security, that the committee had heard counsel on monday the 24th, tuesday the 25th, wednesday the 26th and thursday the 27th days of june, and monday the 1st, tuesday the. Jan 20, 2012 for a competent, conscious, adult patient, the doctor must obtain consent to any bodily contact or else risk a legal action in the tort of battery. Directly involving children in the court process child. West norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1984 q. Children, gillick competency and consent for involvement.
Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1986 ac 112. May 16, 2016 in the case of gillick v west norfolk and wisbech health authority 1986 1 ac 112 lord scarman said, at 185e. Gillick competence ruling in the case gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority, which sought to decide in medical law whether a child is able to consent to his or her own medical treatment, without the need for parental permission or knowledge. Mrs gillick was a mother with five daughters under the age of 16. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority and another. This is because the book deserves to be read as an important diagnosis of what has gone wrong with the regulation of medicine in the united kingdom. Safeguarding and child protection the gillick competency and fraser guidelines help people who work with children to balance the need to listen to childrens wishes with the responsibility to keep them safe. We use cookies to give you the best possible experience. Mrs gillick was a mother of five children, one of whom had sought and received contraceptive advice from a local doctor whilst below the age at which she could lawfully consent to intercourse. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority and the dhss 1986 1 ac 112.
Typical positions of emancipation arise when the minor is married r v d 1984 ac 778, 791 or in the military. The case is binding in england and wales, and has been adopted to varying extents in australia, canada and new zealand. Children, gillick competency and consent for involvement in research. Get free access to the complete judgment in gillick v west norfolk. Oxford university press online resource centre chapter 14. New bibliography other bibliographies cite this for me. Rebecca probert, associate professor, university of warwick.
We can see how the position of children has changed if we compare re agarellis with gillick v. Key concepts office of the victorian information commissioner. The capacity of a child in australia to consent to medical. Gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha 1985 2 wlr 4. Landmark cases in family law landmark cases stephen gilmore. Gillick competency and fraser guidelines nspcc learning. Get free access to the complete judgment in gillick v west norfolk and wisbech aha on casemine. Proxy access for patients aged 11 15 st austell healthcare have decided to allow young people aged 1115 years the right to consent to their parentscarer having access to their systmone online record for requesting medication only. West norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1986 ac 112 see below, where the house of lords held that a child of sufficient age and understanding could consent to contraceptive treatment without parental consent.
1272 227 495 283 1536 1120 1030 482 1075 61 686 454 1021 687 1495 1194 1499 298 222 207 6 148 523 431 266 757 339 1029 840 471 1107 361 168 1168 1059 881 58 514 1256